When Companies Are Allowed to Use AI, but Applicants Aren’t
Essay·EN·Ideas
When Companies Are Allowed to Use AI, but Applicants Aren’t
On the double standard in modern recruiting and the question of when we stopped seeing the people behind applications.
Benjamin Trinidad Segura
4 min read
Create share card
9:16 Story4:5 Feed1:1 Square
Screenshot mode
A company posts a job vacancy. Hundreds of people apply. To reduce the workload, digital systems are used to read résumés, organize information, and possibly help prioritize applications.
Efficiency. Digitalization. Innovation.
An applicant uses ChatGPT to improve the wording of their résumé, present their experience more clearly, or tailor the key information to a specific job.
Suddenly, another question is raised: “Was this written with AI?”
And sometimes, this is even followed by the claim that such applications can be spotted and rejected immediately.
I wonder when we started seeing the use of the same technology as progress on one side and a lack of effort on the other.
Section / 07
Two sides of the same application process
I worked in recruiting for years myself. I know the pressure to fill vacancies, keep managers happy, and handle numerous applications at the same time. I understand why companies look for more efficient solutions.
And today, I also see the other side.
People spend hours reading job ads, tailoring résumés, writing cover letters, and filling out application forms. Often, they receive no personal response. Sometimes, not even a rejection.
When these people use technology to make their applications more efficient and easier to understand, that should be understandable in the first place.
A well-written résumé is not proof of professional competence. But a poorly written one is no proof of its absence, either.
Section / 13
AI is not the real problem
Of course, there is a difference between helpful support and deception. Anyone who uses AI to invent qualifications, work experience, or achievements is misrepresenting their suitability. That is problematic, regardless of which tool was used.
But using AI to better organize, translate, or phrase your actual experience does not change your professional past.
Why should someone be less qualified because they got help with their writing?
And why should the ability to write a perfect résumé matter more for every position than the ability to do the actual job well?
It is possible to have a résumé that is linguistically excellent and still be professionally unsuitable. Likewise, an unremarkable résumé can belong to an exceptionally competent person.
Good hiring decisions must be able to recognize this difference.
Section / 20
When systems start making decisions about people
In a TikTok discussion, I read a thought to the effect that AI is now working against AI, and in the end it will be the better system, not the better applicant, that wins.
That is an exaggeration. Not every applicant tracking system evaluates applications using AI, and not every recruiter rejects AI-assisted résumés.
But behind this comment lies a serious concern.
What happens when applicants increasingly optimize their documents for systems while companies increasingly automate their selection processes?
What happens when we eventually get better at making applications machine-readable than at truly understanding professional suitability?
Then there is a risk that the application process will drift further and further from its original purpose.
Because recruiting should not be about finding out who uses the best keywords or can produce the most persuasive wording.
Recruiting should identify which people, with their skills, experience, and personality, are suited to a role.
Section / 29
Technology should help us look more closely
I am not against AI in recruiting. Quite the opposite. I work extensively with AI myself and develop digital solutions.
I believe AI can provide enormous support in hiring: by reducing administrative work, improving how information is presented, making processes more transparent, and giving us more time for personal conversations.
But this is exactly where the decisive point lies for me.
If we use technology to save time, what do we do with that time afterward?
Do we use it to get to know people better? To assess their experience more thoughtfully? To recognize potential that is not mentioned in a job ad?
Or do we use it merely to reject people even faster?
Perhaps progress does not lie in processing as many applications as possible in as little time as possible.
Perhaps it lies in finally having more time again for the people behind those applications.
Because in the end, what should matter is not whether someone used AI to express themselves clearly. What should matter is whether we took the time to understand them.
Discussion
Continue the thought.
Disagreement is welcome. Disrespect isn’t.
Comments are temporarily unavailable.
The article remains available while the discussion service recovers.